Montessori and Natural Parenting

Deb's son, Will, in Montessori-style exploration (1985)

Maria Montessori, the Italian physician who founded the Montessori Method of education in the early 1900s, was ahead of her time in promoting many principles now considered part of natural parenting. Dr. Montessori encouraged ecological responsibility, love of nature, and healthy living. I’m writing today, though, about her contributions regarding attachment parenting and natural learning.

Montessori and Attachment Parenting

There’s been some controversy about whether or not Dr. Montessori would have encouraged attachment parenting. From a few Montessorians, many have gotten the impression that Maria Montessori was against attachment parenting and its concepts of babywearing and extended breastfeeding.

When my children were little, I ignored any controversy and followed Dr. Montessori’s advice given in her book The Absorbent Mind. Referring to the same controversy and quotes from The Absorbent Mind, Wide Open on the Mommybahn published a post called “Surprising Quirks of Dr. Montessori: She was into AP!” I have to agree.

In The Absorbent Mind, Dr. Montessori says:

[L]et us think, for a moment, of the many peoples of the world who live at different cultural levels from our own. In the matter of child rearing, almost all of these seem to be more enlightened than ourselves – with all our Western ultramodern ideals. Nowhere else, in fact, do we find children treated in a fashion so opposed to their natural needs. In almost all countries, the baby accompanies his mother wherever she goes. Mother and child are inseparable . . . . And this lasts for the whole period of maternal feeding, which is the reason for this close alliance. For the mother has to feed her child, and therefore she cannot leave him at home when she goes out. To this need for food is added their mutual fondness and love . . . . Mother and child are one.

Except where civilization has broken down this custom, no mother ever entrusts her child to someone else. The child shares the mother’s life and is always listening.”

Montessori has positive things to say about babywearing:

All the great human groups, nations and races, have their individual differences; for example, they have different ways of carrying the baby . . . . In most parts of the world, mothers put the baby on a small bed, or in a large bag; they do not carry him in their arms . . . . Some hang the child from their necks, others tie him to their backs, and others again put him in a small basket; but in all countries mothers have found a way of taking their children about with them.

One observes, too, that the little one, going about with his mother, never cries unless he is ill or hurt in some way. Sometimes he may fall asleep, but he does not cry.

Yet the crying of children is a problem in Western countries. How often do we hear parents complain of their children’s incessant crying? They discuss what to do to quieten the baby, and how to keep him happy. The reply of modern psychology is this: “The baby cries and becomes disturbed, has screaming fits and rages, because he is suffering from mental hunger.” And this is the truth. The child is bored. He is being mentally starved, kept prisoner in a confined space offering nothing but frustration to the exercise of his powers. The only remedy is to release him from solitude and let him join in social life. This treatment is naturally and unconsciously adopted in many countries. With us, it must become understood and applied deliberately, as a result of conscious thought.

Montessori also has positive comments about breastfeeding – even prolonged breastfeeding:

Another point is the custom of prolonging the period of maternal feeding. Sometimes this lasts for a year and a half; sometimes for two, or even three years. This has nothing to do with the child’s nutritional needs, because for some time he has been able to assimilate other kinds of food; but prolonged lactation requires the mother to remain with her child, and this satisfies her unconscious need to give her offspring the help of a full social life on which to construct his mind.

At the same time, Montessori places an emphasis on giving babies freedom of movement. In Montessori-style parenting, a low bed (mat) on the floor is recommended to allow your baby to sleep when he or she wants and wake up free to explore. A whole room can be babyproofed and gated, allowing your baby a much larger area than a playpen. If you’re in the room with your baby, he or she will still have freedom along with the security of knowing you are nearby. I used a mixture of freedom to explore and babywearing when my children were babies.

Christina (2) and Will (7) absorbed in Montessori-style natural learning (1992)

Montessori also promotes gentle discipline. I consider Montessori education gentle discipline at its best. It avoids threats, prizes, and punishments. Instead, the child is given lessons and activities to gradually develop self-discipline. If the child shows the need for more instruction, he or she is presented with the lesson again. In an article titled “The Montessori Approach to Discipline,” Mary Conroy and Kitty Williams Bravo recommend following a Montessori approach to discipline at home through a democratic parenting style with “respect for the child’s feelings, choices within acceptable limits, encouragement, conflict resolution, and natural and logical consequences for behavior.”

Montessori and Natural Learning

Although Dr. Montessori made many great contributions to education, I think Montessori’s greatest contribution was her emphasis on following the child. She encouraged teachers and parents to observe the child and follow the child’s interests. Montessori education is naturally a system of individualized learning.

Let us leave the life free to develop within the limits of the good, and let us observe this inner life developing. This is the whole of our mission.
– Maria Montessori

In many ways, Montessori education is a very real, organic way of showing your child respect. Maria Montessori encouraged adults to recognize and respect the child’s need for truth and reality. She emphasized providing real, child-sized tools to acknowledge and support the child’s need for work which develops order, concentration, coordination, and independence.

Here are some of my favorite quotes by Maria Montessori that I think relate:

That humanity which is revealed in its entire intellectual splendor during the sweet and tender age of childhood should be respected with a kind of religious veneration. It is like the sun which appears at dawn or a flower just beginning to bloom. Education cannot be effective unless it helps a child to open up himself to life.

One test of the correctness of educational procedure is the happiness of the child.

[E]ducation is a natural process carried out by the human individual, and is acquired not by listening to words, but by experiences in the environment.

My vision of the future is no longer of people taking exams and proceeding from secondary school to University but of passing from one stage of independence to a higher, by means of their own activity and effort of will.

And so we discovered that education is not something which the teacher does, but that it is a natural process which develops spontaneously in the human being.

Photo Credits: Author

_________________________

Deb Chitwood is the mother of two adult children with college degrees who were homeschooled through high school. At Living Montessori Now, Deb shares information and encouragement for parents and teachers in her posts about Montessori education, homeschooling, and natural parenting.

22 Responses to Montessori and Natural Parenting

  1. Lauren  

    Fascinating! I never knew how Montessori ideas intersected with other AP/NP topics. I love learning about Montessori practices from you, and now I get to add some philosophy as well. :)

  2. Melissa K.  

    Thank you, thank you for bringing everything together in this way! I agree with your sentiments 100%

    As a Montessorian and parent to a still very dependent babe, I also love this quote:

    “It is the nature of the child to be dependent, and it is the nature of dependence to be outgrown. Begrudging dependency because it is not independence is like begrudging winter because it is not yet spring. Dependency blossoms into independence in its own time.”
    -Peggy O’Mara, The Way Back Home

  3. Rachael  

    Thank you, Deb! Would you recommend The Absorbent Mind as a good first read of Montessori’s work? I’d be grateful for any suggestions!

  4. Angie Lile  

    Really great post again Deb. I love the natural learning and am an avid outdoor enthusiast which translates really well to my six-year-olds! :)

  5. Jessie

    Thank you for this! It so clearly links Montessori and Attachment Parenting. Sharing with my friends :)

  6. melissa aka equidae

    thank you for this post. any tips i can use for a 2 year old? right now i am out of ideas on what to do with him….thanks

    • Deb Chitwood @ Living Montessori Now  

      Thanks for your comment, Melissa! I have lots of activities and Montessori information at Living Montessori Now. Here’s the link to my Activity of the Week posts with many Montessori-inspired activities: http://livingmontessorinow.com/category/activity-of-the-week/. I really advocate using practical life activities with 2 year olds because they help so much with order, concentration, coordination, and independence. I have a category for Activities – Practical Life. There’s also a Montessori Techniques category that you might find especially helpful. I even have a giveaway right now of an online Montessori training course and 12 Montessori albums full of curriculum (open through February 8).

      Introducing your son to Montessori activities at age 2 is great! Have fun!

  7. Kitti Young

    WOW i was reading ‘Montessori from the Start’ by Paula Polk Lillard and Linn Lillard Jessen and came across a section on sleep, and it really got me upset as they were practically endorsing controlled crying.
    im very glad i read your post as i love the montessori philosophy and attachment parenting, but didnt really think that they could go together.

  8. meg hicks

    Hi Deb
    Just wanted to let you know I have also written on this topic…thought you might like the link http://montessorihomes.blogspot.com/2011/06/montessori-and-attachment-parenting.html

  9. Montessori Motherload

    I really liked this article and wasn’t surprised when I saw that it was written by Deb at LMN! I love your blog and it was very interesting to read about Montessori and AP!

  10. maresa

    Hi
    I am mother to a 22 month old and only just discovered the montessori approach. Love this website. Thank you!

    A question…. how does montessori look at a child’s sleeping regime? How do you handke/approach a child who does not sleep through the night? Iv read so much about how important sleep is. I presume there must be an alternative to control crying. Any direction will be appreciated. Thanks in advance.

Leave a Comment

Send me an email when additional comments are made on this post.

All comments are subject to moderation, please see the comment policy for more information.